New Authors Beware Of Scam Agents And Publishing Sharks

Scam Agents and Publishing Sharks

Beware of scam agents who prey on new authors.

Publishing a book today is easy with self-publishing services that are generally offered for free online. Or if not free, they are very cheap.

However, this low-cost simplicity has made it a goldmine for shady agents and predatory publishers to deceive new authors trying to publish their book.

If you want to publish a book, be careful about the choices you make.

Beware of the scam agents and sharks in self-publishing

Almost every week, I receive an unsolicited email from a long-time publishing scammer.

It reminds me that the publishing seas are still infested with these untrustworthy sharks.

In general terms, these scammers prey on either an author’s dream of becoming published.

Or on the fact that an author may not know how to self-publish and has given up on traditional publishing but still yearns to be published.

It is easy to fall prey to these dubious publishing experts and land into their expensive traps.

Writers beware. Don’t allow scam agents to fool you. Here are some warning signals for new authors.


Unsolicited invitations to submit your manuscript

Reputable publishers and literary agents all have huge slush piles. None of them would be asking you to make their pile even higher.

If you are asked to submit your manuscript by someone you don’t know, especially by unsolicited email, DO NOT reply.

Your red flags should be flying because it’s 99.9999% sure to be a publishing scam.

If you are approached out of the blue by a publisher you don’t know who wants to publish your book, be careful.

It is a common ploy of scam agents and a clear telltale sign of vanity publishing companies to avoid.


Offers to help you publish

Social media is full of helpful people.

However, many charge a lot of money for their helpfulness. But they may forget to tell you about this upfront.

The new term that there are editors and predators is now a common expression in self-publishing industry circles.

Watch out for uninvited offers to give you feedback on your manuscript for a small reading fee. The fee may not be that small.

Self-publishing is basically free, so DO NOT pay for what you can do or quickly learn to do yourself.


Marketeers and racketeers

Advertising and marketing a book is time-consuming.

There are costs involved for reputable services such as Facebook advertising, Google Adwords, paid blog posts, or an advertorial in a local newspaper.

These are all normal expenses. Most of them are relatively inexpensive and beneficial.

Offers to market a book for a package price by someone you do not know and who guarantees success is a sure sign of a scam.

DO NOT pay for book promotion and marketing services packages.

Arrange and pay advertisers for your book advertising directly with reputable and well-known advertising service providers.


I’m a publisher

There are many legitimate publishers, hybrid publishers, and small press, especially in niche markets.

But you should always check the reputation of a publisher before committing yourself to a contract.

You can check a comprehensive list of publishers and service providers that have been vetted by ALLi (The Alliance of Independent Authors).

DO NOT enter immediately into an agreement with a publisher.

Before you rush in, make sure you check its background, history, reputation, and ethics first. You can also ask for references from authors who used the services of the publisher.


I can do everything

Writer, reader, editor, copy editor, proofreader, publisher, cover designer, book marketer, and self-publishing consultant.

No one person can supply all these services in the publishing process.

Beware of failed writers trying to make a buck on the side by offering services that they are not qualified to provide.

DO NOT pay for amateurs in the publishing world.

If you have to pay for a service, pay for professional services offered by reputable providers.


Make informed choices

After you write a book, there are no easy ways to become a published author and be successful in book publishing.

The best way to avoid scammers and the possibility of being ripped off is to understand that publishing a book will be a tough job.

For those authors and writers who are trying to publish for the first time, there are safe avenues to publish a book.


Traditional Publishing

Traditional publishing is the old-fashioned business model of publishing a book.

You need to approach literary agents with the hope of signing a contract. After that, then having your book published and promoted by one of the large publishing houses.

It is the most difficult and time-consuming method. It will involve sending submissions to a lot of agents and then waiting and hoping.

The rejection rate is so high these days that a new author will need a lot of luck. It is not impossible, of course. But for new writers, it is not very easy at all.


Pros: No publishing costs to an author, and sometimes pay an advance.

Cons: Difficult to get published, and royalties can be quite low. An author also must sign away the rights to a book.



As the name implies, self-publishing means that an author will have to do everything necessary to publish a book.

Then you need to market it and hopefully sell enough copies online to get a return on your time invested in writing and self-publishing a book.

For authors who are new to electronic self-publishing, it will be a learning curve.

You will need to have a good knowledge of basic word processing, computer, and Internet skills.

The basic skills include uploading files, formatting Word styles, and converting to mobi and epub files.

You also need to do image resizing, as well as have a good understanding of file management.

Self-publishing is generally free. But there will be some costs in preparing a book for publication.

These could include expenses for a book cover, editing, and proofreading.

If you think self-publishing technology is beyond your ability, you could consider an assisted self-publishing service.

But always make sure you retain all the rights to your book. Also, check that the online book retailers pay royalties to you directly.


Pros: Quick to publish in ebook or paperback. Free or at least very cheap, depending on preparation costs. Authors own all their book rights. If your book sells, you receive a high royalty rate of usually 60-70% per copy.

Cons: Some computer skills to learn. All facets of publishing, marketing, and selling are the responsibility of the author.


What to expect to pay for reputable services

Pre-made ebook cover. US$30-60

Custom-made book cover. US$250-500

Proofreading and correction – basic. US$ 200-400 for approx 80,000 words.

Assisted self-publishing services. Preparation of manuscript files and publishing for you on Kindle Direct Publishing for ebook and paperback, and Smashwords or Draft2digital for ebook distribution. US$200-250.


Vanity Publishing

Vanity publishing has been frowned upon for a long time. But there are still quite a few large vanity publishing houses around.

Some traditional publishers used the services of one vanity publisher. It was a means to offer expensive self-publishing packages to new authors. But it was only vanity publishing in a new form.

Thankfully, most have closed down these expensive pseudo-self-publishing services now.

Unfortunately, some vanity publishers have re-branded and re-named their services as self-publishing, which it definitely is not.


Never confuse self-publishing with vanity publishing

It doesn’t matter how well-known or established vanity publishing is or if it goes by a new name.

New authors need to be aware that it will be a very, very expensive way to publish a book.

Most of their websites make no mention of the prices they will charge, which should be a warning.

You can read my take on Newman Springs Publishing as an example of what to look for when you are deciding on a book publisher.

Vanity publishing means that the author pays for everything. It can often amount to thousands of dollars.

This cost does not typically include marketing a book other than that it will possibly be available on the vanity publisher’s website.

There is rarely a mention of what book sales you can expect to get.

Vanity publishing is easy. But it is an awfully expensive way to fill your basement with 5,000 copies of a book, which you may or probably, may not ever sell.

What’s the key warning sign that you are dealing with a vanity press? It is when the publisher finally asks you to pay a considerable amount of money upfront to publish your book.

It is the moment when the words scam agents and publishing sharks should spring to your mind very quickly.

Update: Dog Ear Publishing, which had a very bad reputation, has reopened as Bookplate Press, so beware. You can read more about it in this watchdog advisory article on ALLi.


Vanity publishers are not interested in selling your book

Vanity publishers only want to sell books to you, the author.

There have also been many complaints about the high-pressure business practices of certain vanity publishers.

Be careful. Search the Internet for customer feedback on any company you might be considering.

Do it before you commit yourself to a publishing contract and handing over your money.

Samita Sarkar wrote an excellent article about how to spot publishing scams for the Huffington Post.

Her warning signals in the piece are very good advice. These four are classic for high-pressure selling vanity publishers and scam agents.

“The publisher’s website contains little to no information to attract readers, and is almost entirely devoted to selling to authors.”

“The website contains slogans about helping authors, “tell their story” by “letting the experts guide them,” etc.”

“In exchange for your name, email address, and phone number, you can download a free publishing guide.”

“Expect a call later on that same day, before even opening the guide.”

I can personally attest to this last point. I was once pestered with almost daily phone calls for over two months by one of the most well-known vanity publishers.


Pros: Trade publishing quality books with paid editing and cover design services.

Cons: Annoying high-pressure selling by some vanity publishers. Usually extremely expensive with no effective marketing support. 



As a new author, if you receive an offer that is too good to be true, it surely will be.

When you publish a book in any form, there is no guarantee of success. No amount of money thrown at a publisher will make it any easier to succeed.

In my opinion, a new author has two sensible choices when it comes to publishing a book.

The first is to take the traditional publishing route. Try to find and work with a literary agent or a reputable small press publishing house.

The second option is to self-publish and enjoy the learning curve and the journey.

Both are tough. But that’s the reality of book publishing today. There is no easy way.


Helpful links for new authors

Publishing Services Rated By ALLi (The Alliance of Independent Authors)

List of Literary Agents UK & US

Kindle Direct Publishing




Derek Haines

A Cambridge CELTA English teacher and author with a passion for writing and all forms of publishing. My days are spent writing and blogging, as well as testing and taming new technology.

Avatar for Derek Haines

149 thoughts on “New Authors Beware Of Scam Agents And Publishing Sharks

  • Avatar for Lynn Dowless
    November 20, 2021 at 12:30 am

    There is a book out called “Become Traditionally Published,” by L Horne. Nothing out there beats being traditionally published, no matter who tries to convince one otherwise. Yeah, you have those one in a million true blue success stories, such as Amanda Hockings, for example. The overwhelming average rank and file barely even sells a book. As BTP clearly explains in vivid details, one can still have great publishing success, and may well bank some money in the process, however.

  • Avatar for Paul Cherry
    February 2, 2021 at 11:14 pm

    Beacon Books has $1700 of my money and I have nothing! Todd Adams was my agent also. I am to fool for trusting.

    • Avatar for Jim Taylor
      February 27, 2021 at 4:09 pm

      I also got a call from one of Beacon Books. Wanted to market my book and so decided to give it a go. I’m not sure how they did it but I started receiving calls from bookstores to display my book

  • Avatar for Jamie
    January 12, 2021 at 12:04 pm

    Thanks for the post. I sense that you mean well but I also feel like your analysis is a bit simplistic.

    What is the vanity in “vanity publishing”? It refers to the author, the author who is not looking at publishing as a profit driven business (which it is) but as some kind of vehicle for their personal dreams of recognition.

    There are plenty of sharks for sure but I would be careful using the word scam.

    One of the fastest growing publishing companies is Callisto Media who approach writers and commission books on various subjects. They pay the author a set amount to write the book and the writer is credited as author, but that’s it…The writer gets no further money when their book becomes a bestseller, as many of Callistos books do.

    Is paying a writer 3K for a book that goes on to make the publisher 100k+ a scam? It’s certainly good business.

    If you want to just get your book published you can,
    1.Hire a book cover designer
    2.Hire a book formatter
    3. Hire a proofreader (optional)
    4. Login to KDP or IngramSpark and publish your book

    That’s it, job done.

    If you want to make money from your work you need to become a professional (self) publisher and take on ALL the work and effort to make that happen.

    There is no universe in which you write something and someone comes along and says “Your work here is done. Relax now while I go off and turn your book into a bestseller and blockbuster movie and give you all the money.”

  • Avatar for Bobbie Suzanne Fitz
    December 16, 2020 at 3:31 am

    Hi! Please let me know if you have been contacted by Rabiya Matthews of Silver Ink Literacy Agency. I am considering the opportunity to be reviewed by the Trifecta Review. It promises endorsement of the book to HarperCollins and Simon & Schuster. Just curious of any others have heard this.

    • Avatar for Jane Paul
      May 7, 2021 at 4:51 pm

      Silver Ink is another scammer! They promised me my book would be taken up by a well known publishing house once it was found to be ‘editorally sound’. It was to go before a board for final approval. This book had already be reviwed, reprinted, and had a five star Amazon rating.The scam? Well they wanted mevto pay $2000 for ‘corrections with no guarantee it would be accepted.!!

  • Avatar for Steven Hutson
    December 4, 2020 at 3:26 am

    I don’t understand. Why it is bad for an agent to call a writer?

  • Avatar for George
    November 22, 2020 at 11:29 am

    amazon KDP will terminate an account over a book KDP blocks and when a book is blocked by KDP, they send you an email that you can change title or cover image and upload it again. However, sometimes it triggers a “book blocked” and just like myself and others a few days later. bam! account is terminated! I had nearly 1K titles. KDP, first of all, needs a better system… and if the user apologizes for a mistake and their account is in good standing (mine was!) that shouldn’t be grounds to automatically terminate. Also,Jeff Bezos needs to run KDP division better. (most KDP people are not in America…)

    • Avatar for Jamie
      January 12, 2021 at 11:27 am

      ” Also,Jeff Bezos needs to run KDP division better. (most KDP people are not in America…)”

      Are you suggesting that KDP would be run better if it was only open to US citizens!?


Add Your Comment

Your email address will not be published.

To prevent spam, all comments are moderated and will be published upon approval. Submit your comment only once, please.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.