What is ISBN?
It is the bar code and International Standard Book Number (ISBN) you see on the copyright page and the back of books. For a publisher, it is a unique identifier.
All published books require a unique number to identify the publishing company and the title. The numbering systems give enough information about a book to make each one a unique ISBN.
The Group, Publisher prefix, and Title numbers are easy to identify and understand. The last digit of the number, the check digit, is used for error detection, and the EAN is the European Article Number.
Why are there two ISBNs?
From 1970 books have had a unique 10-digit ISBN.
Then in 2007, the 13-digit number was added to overcome a perceived shortage of ISBNs in some parts of the world.
The shortage hasn’t seemed to have eventuated, though. Most books now have two numbers, 10 digits and 13 digits, which makes the system a little confusing.
The only points to understand are that these numbers are essential to the supply chain for books.
If you want to sell your book, you will need an assigned ISBN for every version of your book.
Every version means paperback, hardcover book, ebook, and audiobook.
How do you get an ISBN?
You have two choices to obtain an ISBN. You can buy one or get a free ISBN.
If you want to buy your numbers, you will need to contact an international ISBN agency to get a national ISBN.
In the United States, R. R. Bowker is the sole provider of ISBN numbers.
When purchasing ISBNs, prices range from about US$125 for a single number. But you can buy packages of 10 for around $295. Source Bowker.
However, if you publish with Amazon, Smashwords, Draft2Digital, or in fact, most self-publishing platforms, they all assign a free ISBN.
So what’s going on here?
Do you need to buy an ISBN?
Let’s look at what happens if you buy ISBNs.
The logical benefit of owning your ISBN is that if you publish and make your book available on many retailers, your sales data for your book titles will be cumulative.
So if you are hoping to make it into the New York Times bestsellers, having your book sales divided up isn’t going to help at all.
There is also a sense that you are in control because you can use the same ISBN on every publishing platform you use.
All of that is logical, and it makes sense.
Except that publishing platforms and online retailers don’t necessarily play the same game, especially when it comes to ebooks.
Do you need an ISBN for ebooks?
On Amazon, you can’t use an ISBN because it uses an ASIN (Amazon Standard Identification Number) to identify Kindle ebooks. Amazon is also usually listed as the publisher.
However, some retailers, such as Kobo and Tolino, downstream to smaller retailers that do not support ISBN search.
However, Apple and B&N Nook support it. But, Apple only supports the 13 digit number.
So you can have an ISBN for most epub versions you publish, but sales from your biggest selling outlet, Amazon, won’t count because you can’t use your ISBN.
Remember that you need a separate number for all your print and ebook versions. It can all become a confusing and expensive exercise.
Lastly, if you buy an ISBN and apply it to an existing title, it will become a totally new book.
Then you will lose all your previous sales data. So forget about buying one if your book is already self-published.
Is a free ISBN a better choice?
Well, yes. They are free, which is one big plus.
The biggest drawback is that you cannot transfer them between publisher services and retailers.
If you have published on Smashwords and used a free ISBN, you cannot use that number to publish with Draft2Digital.
It’s the same with print books. If you publish with Lulu, you cannot transfer that number to Blurb or KDP.
When you check your Amazon Author page, there is a tab to check your NPD Bookscan data.
With free ISBNs, you will be lucky to see much activity if you publish your book under a few different numbers.
On the plus side, though, search engines treat free and paid ISBNs as the same.
Both Google and Bing use an ISBN database to return results for all books in print as well as ebooks and audiobooks.
An ISBN identifies a book, so your title will be treated exactly the same as Harry Potter!
Update note: Free ISBNs are no longer available on Amazon KDP for low content books.
What’s the best option for ISBNs?
Do you really require an ISBN? There is no right or wrong answer.
If you want to be in control of your book publishing, and you can afford the considerable extra cost, you might think about buying an ISBN.
Bear in mind, though, that you will need one for every book version. So if you have a paperback, ebook, and audiobook, your ISBN cost will be a minimum of $300.
If you have more than one title, the costs can add up very quickly.
Also, if you have existing titles and change the ISBN, you will lose your book’s data and basically be starting from scratch with a new book.
With a free number, there are not a lot of issues that should concern most self-publishing authors.
The only downside is that your book sales will not be calculated as a total across all retailers.
But unless you are selling hundreds of print book copies a week, this will not be much of an issue.
Well, unless you think your book has a chance of getting into the national bestseller lists.
There are more worthwhile expenses such as book covers, editing, and book promotion that can help get book sales.
An ISBN is certainly not going to do a lot to help sell your book.
In a way, ISBNs are a relic of a past time when books were only sold in brick and mortar stores as part of a tightly controlled market.
The ebook and self-publishing have thrown a huge spanner into the works.
It is impossible now to track every book and every sale, which was the case in 1970.
Yes, the ISBN and bar code are still useful for making every book unique.
But apart from that benefit, there is not much else. If you mainly sell Kindle ebooks or get an income from Kindle Unlimited, an ISBN is a non-event.
Amazon assigns an Amazon Standard Identification Number (ASIN) number to ebooks.
Amazon uses a 10 or 13-digit International Standard Book Number (ISBN) for books in other formats. These are usually a free ISBN.
If you sell print book copies on Amazon and Barnes & Noble, does it matter what number is on the back of each copy?
Self-publishers know that a large proportion of their ebook sales will come from Amazon.
So why fret about a different number on the small percentage of sales from Apple, Nook, and Kobo?
In all honesty, I have never worried about what numbers or codes are on my books.
I will never sell enough to threaten Ian Rankin or James Patterson, so why would I spend a lot of money on a number?.
The only numbers that count are dollars in the bank each month, and I have never considered that an identifying number helps much in this regard.
But perhaps, ISBNs can still be useful in certain situations.